Who is the Blackest Pencil Liner in the Land?

Hello Beautiful People,

     On a recent browsing at Sephora I decided to swatch some of the blackest pencil liners that were available in store at that point. I will note that Make Up For Ever’s liner was sold out at the time so its not apart of this swatch test. I was on a mission to find the BLACKEST liner available that at the same time wouldn’t move. I tested the following brands:

  • Stila
  • Nars
  • Clique
  • Too Faced
  • Benefit’s Bad Gal Liner 
  • Buxom 
  • Sephora

 Here are the swatches …

Stila, Nars, Clinique, Too Faced, Benefits Bad Gal Liner, Buxom, and Sephora
So who won?
1st Place: STILA
2nd Place: TOO FACED
3rd Place: Buxom
Who stayed on the longest? I used makeup remover and a pad and the two that I had to really scrub off was  STILA and TOO FACED with STILA being the winner. So there you have it. Go get your STILA!

1 thought on “Who is the Blackest Pencil Liner in the Land?

  1. Anonymous says:

    THanks for this post. I’ve been looking for a good black pencil. I’ve stuck with gel for the longest because I haven’t found a good deep black


What do you have to say?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.